duplexloan

For New Yorkers buying a 2-4 family home to live in

NH Assets team · reviewed 2026-11-03

The FHA self-sufficiency test for three- and four-unit homes

Disclosure: duplexloan.com is published by NH Assets. We’re not a lender or mortgage broker and we don’t take applications. At launch we have no partners and receive no compensation of any kind, and all forms are off. Not legal or financial advice.

Short answer: On an FHA loan for a three- or four-unit property, the building has to be able to carry itself. Take the appraiser’s market rent for every unit, including the one you’ll live in, and subtract the greater of the appraiser’s vacancy-and-maintenance estimate or 25%. The full monthly PITI (principal, interest, taxes and insurance) divided by that net figure may not exceed 100%. Your salary doesn’t enter this test at all.

General information only. Not legal or financial advice. Passing this test is not an approval.

Related: /rent-from-units/, /fha-duplex/, /conventional-vs-fha/


The rule, quoted

HUD Handbook 4000.1 (Update 18, last revised August 12, 2026), Section II.A.1:

“The PITI divided by the monthly Net Self-Sufficiency Rental Income may not exceed 100 percent for three- to four-unit Properties.”

Net Self-Sufficiency Rental Income is calculated “by using the Appraiser’s estimate of fair market rent from all units, including the unit the Borrower chooses for occupancy, and subtracting the greater of the Appraiser’s estimate for vacancies and maintenance, or 25 percent of the fair market rent.”

Duplexes are exempt. This test is only for three and four units.

The test in four lines

  1. Gross market rent = appraiser’s market rent for all units, yours included
  2. Deduction = the greater of (appraiser’s vacancy and maintenance estimate) or (25% × gross market rent)
  3. Net = gross − deduction
  4. Pass if PITI ÷ net ≤ 100%, which is the same as PITI ≤ net

Note what’s not in it: leases, your income, and your own housing costs. The figures come from the appraisal.

Worked example: a three-family in Brooklyn (hypothetical)

All numbers are made up:

Line Amount
Unit 1 (you), market rent per appraiser $3,200
Unit 2, market rent $3,000
Unit 3, market rent $2,800
Gross market rent $9,000
Appraiser’s vacancy/maintenance estimate $1,800 (20%)
25% floor $2,250
Deduction (greater of the two) $2,250
Net self-sufficiency rent $6,750
Proposed PITI $7,100
PITI ÷ net 105%: fails

With monthly PITI of $7,100, this building doesn’t pass. The PITI must come down to $6,750 or less.

Working backward: the most PITI a building supports

Because the deduction is at least 25%, the highest PITI that can pass is 75% of gross market rent. The figure is lower if the appraiser’s vacancy estimate is above 25%.

Gross market rent (hypothetical) PITI ceiling at the 25% floor
$8,000 $6,000
$10,000 $7,500
$12,000 $9,000

Run this before you make an offer. Price, rate, taxes and insurance all feed the PITI, and NYC property taxes and insurance on older multi-family buildings can move it a lot.

How to fix a fail

The ratio has two sides, and only one is in your control.

Lower the PITI:

Challenge the rent side, carefully:

Or change the loan:

The other three-to-four-unit rules

Passing this test is only one step. FHA adds:

Your own qualifying is a separate step, and it can use 75% of the other units’ rent as income. That’s a different calculation from this test. See /rent-from-units/.

Two common mix-ups

“My unit doesn’t count.” It does. The test includes the market rent for the unit you’ll occupy, even though you won’t pay yourself rent.

“It’s the same 75% as the income rule.” Not quite. The income rule takes 75% of the lower of lease or market rent for the units that are rented. This test deducts the greater of the appraiser’s estimate or 25% from all units’ market rent. Two tests, two inputs.

FAQ

Does a duplex need to pass the self-sufficiency test? No. The handbook applies it to three- to four-unit properties.

Can my salary make up a shortfall? Not in this test. It compares the PITI with the building’s net rent only.

What PITI is used? The full proposed monthly principal, interest, taxes and insurance on the new loan. Ask your lender to show you its figure.

Is 100% a target? It’s the maximum. Anything at or under 100% passes this test. Other rules still apply.

Sources

Not legal or financial advice. Last reviewed 2026-11-03 by the NH Assets team.

Prepared by the NH Assets team · Not legal or financial advice · Preview build, not published

Disclosures Privacy Terms