duplexloan

For New Yorkers buying a 2-4 family home to live in

NH Assets team · reviewed 2026-11-06

No-cash-out refinance on a 2–4 unit home: FHA vs Fannie

Disclosure: duplexloan.com is published by NH Assets. We’re not a lender or mortgage broker and we don’t take applications. At launch we have no partners and receive no compensation of any kind, and all forms are off. Not legal or financial advice.

Short answer: FHA and Fannie Mae use different names and different rules for a refinance that doesn’t pull equity out. FHA has three separate no-cash-out types — Rate and Term, Simple Refinance, and Streamline Refinance — each with its own occupancy, LTV/CLTV, appraisal and seasoning rules, and a $500 cash-back limit when estimates are used. Fannie Mae calls its version a limited cash-out refinance: cash back is capped at the greater of 1% of the new loan amount or $2,000, and the Eligibility Matrix ceiling for a 2–4 unit principal residence is 95% under DU (lower for high-balance loans: 2 unit < 85%, 3–4 unit < 75%) and 85% (2 units) / 75% (3–4 units) under manual underwriting. None of these are cash-out ceilings, and the cash-out ceilings are not these. This page quotes the handbooks. It is not a loan decision.

General information only. Not legal or financial advice. No rate, approval, payment, or loan amount is promised here. Lenders apply their own overlays in addition to FHA and Fannie rules.

Related on this site: /cash-out-refinance-2-4-units/, /conventional-vs-fha/, /fha-duplex/, /nyc-2-4-unit-loan-limits/


Four labels, four rule sets

FHA Rate and Term FHA Simple Refinance FHA Streamline Refinance Fannie limited cash-out (LCO)
Loan being paid off Any mortgage An existing FHA-insured mortgage An existing FHA-insured first lien An existing first mortgage
Occupancy (as printed) Owner-occupied principal residence or HUD-approved secondary residence Owner-occupied principal or HUD-approved secondary residence Principal, HUD-approved secondary, or non-owner occupied Matrix rows by occupancy; this page uses the principal residence rows only
Max LTV 97.75% if owner-occupied 12 months (or since acquisition) at case number; 85% otherwise 97.75% principal residence Base loan capped by the existing loan’s balance, not by an LTV 2–4 units: 95% DU; manual 85% (2 units) / 75% (3–4 units)
Max CLTV 97.75% 97.75% principal residence No maximum CLTV Matrix lists LTV/CLTV/HCLTV together
Appraisal Not exempted; the maximum-mortgage text counts repairs required by the appraisal Not exempted; same appraisal-repair line Not required Not covered in B2-1.3-02
Cash to borrower Estimates may not produce more than $500 Same $500 limit Same $500 limit Greater of 1% of new loan or $2,000

Sources: HUD Handbook 4000.1, Update 18, II.A.8.d.i and II.A.8.d.vi, printed pp. 434–454 (issued 8/12/2026; refinances section labeled 11/10/2026; revalidated 2026-11-06 09:31:55 EST); Fannie Mae B2-1.3-02 (topic 10/08/2025; site footer Published November 04, 2026; retrieved 2026-11-06 09:31:54 EST); Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026; DU Version 12.1; retrieved 2026-11-06 09:31:54 EST).

Do not merge these columns. A Streamline rule is not a Simple Refinance rule, and neither is a Fannie rule.

Not the cash-out numbers. Fannie’s 75% (2–4 unit principal residence) and FHA’s 80% of Adjusted Value are cash-out maximums. They are covered on /cash-out-refinance-2-4-units/ and do not apply to the refinances on this page.


FHA: what “no cash-out” means

“A No Cash-Out Refinance is a refinance of any Mortgage in which the mortgage proceeds are limited to the purpose of extinguishing the existing debt and costs associated with the transaction. FHA offers three types of no cash-out refinances:”

Source: HUD 4000.1 Update 18, II.A.8.d.i(B)(2), printed p. 434.

“Rate and Term refers to a no cash-out refinance of any Mortgage in which all proceeds are used to pay existing mortgage liens on the subject Property and costs associated with the transaction.”

“Simple Refinance refers to a no cash-out refinance of an existing FHA-insured Mortgage in which all proceeds are used to pay the existing FHA-insured mortgage lien on the subject Property and costs associated with the transaction.”

“Streamline Refinance refers to the refinance of an existing FHA-insured Mortgage requiring limited Borrower credit documentation and underwriting. There are two different streamline options available.”

Source: same PDF, p. 434. The two Streamline options are credit qualifying (credit and capacity analysis, no appraisal) and non-credit qualifying (no credit or capacity analysis, no appraisal), pp. 434–435.

For every FHA refinance type:

“At least one Borrower on the refinancing Mortgage must hold title to the Property being refinanced prior to case number assignment.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.ii(B), p. 435. FHA-to-FHA refinances also need a Refinance Authorization Number from FHA Connection, and refinancing an FHA loan into another FHA loan within 3 years brings a UFMIP refund credit (pp. 435–436). Premium math lives on /fha-mip-2-4-units/; it is not repeated here.

Unit count

In the no-cash-out section (II.A.8.d.vi, pp. 439–454), the Rate and Term, Simple and Streamline maximums are not split by 1-unit versus 2–4 units. That is a scoped reading of that section only — not a claim that other unit-specific underwriting rules (reserves, rental income, self-sufficiency on 3–4 units) disappear. Those live on /fha-duplex/, /rent-from-units/ and /self-sufficiency-test/ and are not rewritten here.


FHA Rate and Term

Occupancy

“Rate and Term refinance transactions are only permitted on owner-occupied Principal Residences and HUD-approved Secondary Residences.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(A)(1)(a), p. 439. The lender reviews employment documentation or utility bills to show the borrower currently occupies the property and to determine how long the borrower has occupied it as a principal residence (same page).

Max LTV depends on 12 months of occupancy at case number

“The maximum LTV for a Rate and Term refinance is: • 97.75 percent for Principal Residences that have been owner-occupied for the previous 12 months, or owner-occupied since acquisition if acquired within 12 months, at case number assignment; • 85 percent for a Borrower who has occupied the subject Property as their Principal Residence for fewer than 12 months prior to the case number assignment date; or if owned less than 12 months, has not occupied the Property for that entire period of ownership; or • 85 percent for all HUD-approved Secondary Residences.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(A)(2)(a), p. 440. The clock is anchored to case-number assignment, not closing.

“The maximum CLTV ratio for a Rate and Term refinance is 97.75 percent. For open-end line of credit, the Mortgagee must utilize the maximum accessible credit limit of the subordinate lien to calculate the CLTV ratio.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(A)(2)(c), p. 442.

Maximum mortgage amount

The Rate and Term maximum is the lesser of the Nationwide Mortgage Limit, the maximum LTV above, or existing debt plus costs of the transaction, less any UFMIP refund (pp. 440–441). Existing debt includes the first mortgage, any purchase-money junior mortgage, and junior liens over 12 months old — but:

“If the balance or any portion of an equity line of credit in excess of $1,000 was advanced within the past 12 months and was for purposes other than repairs and rehabilitation of the Property, that portion above and beyond $1,000 of the line of credit is not eligible for inclusion in the new Mortgage;”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(A)(2)(b)(i), pp. 440–441. County loan-limit figures are on /nyc-2-4-unit-loan-limits/.

Buying out a title holder’s equity (for example, under a divorce decree or settlement agreement) is treated as property-related indebtedness that may be included, with the decree or agreement documented (p. 441).

The $500 cash-back limit

“The Mortgagee may utilize estimates of existing debts and costs in calculating the maximum mortgage amount to the extent that the actual debts and costs do not result in the Borrower receiving greater than $500 cash back at mortgage Disbursement.”

Source: p. 442. A refund of the borrower’s unused escrow balance from the old loan does not count toward the $500, and excess cash back may be applied to reduce the new principal balance (same page).

Payment history (manually underwritten)

“For all mortgages on all properties with greater than six months history, the Borrower must have made all Mortgage Payments within the month due for the six months prior to case number assignment and have no more than one 30-Day late payment for the previous six months for all mortgages.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(A)(1)(b), p. 439. After a forbearance plan, the borrower must have completed the plan and made at least three consecutive payments within the month due; payments for the month before disbursement must also be made (same page).


FHA Simple Refinance

“Simple Refinance is only permissible for owner-occupied Principal or HUD-approved Secondary Residences.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(B)(1)(a), p. 442.

“The maximum LTV ratio for a Simple Refinance is: • 97.75 percent for Principal Residences; and • 85 percent for HUD-approved Secondary Residences.”

“The maximum CLTV for a Simple Refinance is: • 97.75 percent for Principal Residences; and • 85 percent for HUD-approved Secondary Residences.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(B)(2), p. 444. Unlike Rate and Term, the Simple Refinance LTV text as printed does not carry the 12-month occupancy split. The loan paid off must be the existing FHA-insured first mortgage, and the maximum mortgage is built from that balance plus listed items and costs, less any UFMIP refund (p. 444). The same $500 cash-back limit on estimates applies (p. 444). Payment-history wording for manual underwriting matches the Rate and Term text (p. 443).


FHA Streamline Refinance

“Streamline Refinance may be used when the proceeds of the Mortgage are used to extinguish an existing FHA-insured first mortgage lien. Mortgagees must manually underwrite all Streamline Refinances in accordance with the guidance provided in this section.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(C), p. 445. TOTAL Mortgage Scorecard findings are invalid on a Streamline (p. 449).

Occupancy

“Streamline Refinances may be used for Principal Residences, HUD-approved Secondary Residences, or non-owner occupied Properties.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(C)(2)(a), p. 446. If the lender cannot evidence principal or secondary occupancy, it must process the Streamline as non-owner occupied, and non-owner occupied and secondary residences may Streamline only into a fixed-rate mortgage (pp. 447–448). This site covers owner-occupants only.

Seasoning (at case-number assignment)

“On the date of the FHA case number assignment: • the Borrower must have made at least six payments on the FHA-insured Mortgage that is being refinanced […] • at least six full months must have passed since the first payment due date of the Mortgage that is being refinanced; • at least 210 Days must have passed from the Closing Date of the Mortgage that is being refinanced; and • if the Borrower assumed the Mortgage that is being refinanced, they must have made six payments since the time of assumption.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(C)(4)(a), pp. 448–449. Four tests, one anchor date. Do not shorten them to “six months.”

Net tangible benefit

“A Net Tangible Benefit is a reduced Combined Rate, a change from an ARM to a fixed rate Mortgage, and/or a reduced term that results in a financial benefit to the Borrower.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(C)(4)(c)(i), p. 449. The handbook’s threshold charts are stated in rate terms; this page does not quote rates, so read them in the source.

Loan size, CLTV, appraisal

Credit qualifying vs non-credit qualifying

“A Borrower is eligible for a Streamline Refinance without credit qualification if all Borrowers on the existing Mortgage remain as Borrowers on the new Mortgage.”

Source: II.A.8.d.vi(C)(5)(a), p. 453 (with a divorce, legal separation or death exception on the same pages). For credit qualifying, at least one existing borrower must remain, and the loan must meet all manual-underwriting requirements except appraisal and LTV calculations (p. 454).


Fannie Mae: limited cash-out refinance

Selling Guide B2-1.3-02, Limited Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (topic 10/08/2025).

What qualifies

“The transaction is being used to obtain a new first mortgage secured by the same property to […] pay off an existing first mortgage (including an existing HELOC in first-lien position);”

“At least one borrower on the new loan must be an owner (on title) of the subject property at the time of the initial application.”

Source: B2-1.3-02, Eligibility Requirements. Listed exceptions include documented inheritance or a legal award (divorce, separation, or dissolution of a domestic partnership), a qualifying inter vivos revocable trust, and a borrower already obligated on the loan but not on title (including a majority-owned or controlled LLC, with ownership moved to the individual borrower).

“Only subordinate liens used to purchase the property may be paid off and included in the new mortgage.”

Source: same section (PACE and other energy-related debt is the stated exception). A property listed for sale must be off the market on or before disbursement (same section).

Cash back

“providing cash back to the borrower (or any other party) in an amount that, in aggregate, does not exceed the greater of 1% of the new refinance loan amount or $2,000;”

Source: same page, Acceptable Uses. Refunds of overpaid fees and charges required by federal or state law are outside that cap when the settlement statement identifies them and the file documents them (Cash Back). Acceptable uses also include changing the rate and/or term, paying off the existing first mortgage (including prepayment penalties and late fees), and financing closing costs, points and prepaid items.

Compare, don’t merge: FHA’s $500 is a limit on cash back produced by estimates; Fannie’s figure is the greater of 1% or $2,000. Different programs, different wording.

When it becomes a cash-out refinance

“When the following conditions exist, the transaction is ineligible as a limited cash-out refinance and must be treated as a cash-out refinance: no outstanding first lien on the subject property […]; the proceeds are used to pay off a subordinate lien that was not used to purchase the property […]; the borrower finances the payment of real estate taxes that are more than 60 days delinquent for the subject property in the loan amount; and a short-term refinance mortgage loan that combines a first mortgage and a non-purchase-money subordinate mortgage into a new first mortgage or any refinance of that loan within six months.”

Source: same page, Ineligible Transactions. If one of these applies, the cash-out rules and ceilings on /cash-out-refinance-2-4-units/ govern instead.

Co-owner buyout

“A transaction that requires one owner to buy out the interest of another owner […] is considered a limited cash-out refinance if the secured property was jointly owned for at least 12 months preceding the disbursement date of the new mortgage loan.”

Source: same page. All parties sign a written agreement, and the borrower who acquires sole ownership may not receive any of the proceeds.

Subordinate financing

New subordinate financing taken with the refinance keeps limited cash-out treatment if the first mortgage meets the limited cash-out criteria, and “It is acceptable for borrowers to obtain cash from the proceeds of the new subordinate mortgage.” Existing subordinate liens that stay must be clearly subordinate. Source: same page.

No stated clock in B2-1.3-02

B2-1.3-02 does not state an occupancy-duration clock or an existing-loan age test for a standard limited cash-out refinance. Its 12-month figures attach to the co-owner buyout (joint ownership) and installment land contracts, and its six-month figure attaches to the short-term combined-refinance rule above. Do not import FHA’s case-number clocks — or Fannie’s cash-out note-date and title clocks — into this passage. Other Selling Guide topics may apply to a given loan; this page does not claim to cover them.


Fannie Eligibility Matrix: limited cash-out ceilings for 2–4 units

The matrix prints Purchase and Limited Cash-Out Refinance in the same principal-residence row. Figures below are FRM/ARM maximum LTV/CLTV/HCLTV.

Principal residence, purchase / limited cash-out DU (p. 2) Manual (p. 4)
1 unit (contrast) FRM 97% / ARM 95% 95%
2 units 95%; high-balance < 85% 85%
3–4 units 95%; high-balance < 75% 75%

Source: Eligibility Matrix, August 5, 2026, printed pp. 2 and 4, note (2) on p. 8 (retrieved 2026-11-06 09:31:54 EST; pages visually checked).

“(2) LTV, CLTV, or HCLTV Ratios for High-Balance 2-4 Unit Properties (including Manufactured Homes): • 2 unit: < 85% • 3-4 unit: < 75%”

Source: same matrix, p. 8. High-balance loans must be underwritten with DU (p. 7). In NYC, loan amounts on 2–4 unit homes can fall in the high-balance range; whether a given amount does depends on the county limit — see /nyc-2-4-unit-loan-limits/. This page does not decide that for any loan.

A published ceiling is not an approval.


Clocks that must stay separate

Program Clock Anchor
FHA Rate and Term 12 months owner-occupied (or since acquisition) → 97.75%; fewer → 85% Case-number assignment
FHA Rate and Term / Simple (manual) Six months of on-time payments, no more than one 30-day late Before case-number assignment
FHA Streamline Six payments; six full months since first payment due; 210 days since closing On the date of case-number assignment
FHA (all refinances) At least one borrower on title Before case-number assignment
Fannie LCO At least one borrower on title At initial application
Fannie LCO co-owner buyout Jointly owned 12 months Before disbursement

Do not collapse these clocks into one another, or into the cash-out clocks on /cash-out-refinance-2-4-units/.


Update 18 timing caveat

Handbook changes that are not Mortgagee-Letter changes “May be implemented immediately, but must be implemented no later than November 10, 2026”; changes reflecting Mortgagee Letters keep their previously announced effective dates. Source: Update 18 transmittal, printed p. 7. The refinances section is labeled 11/10/2026 while footers say Last Revised 8/12/2026. This page cites the published Update 18 text; it does not claim every change was mandatory on November 6, 2026.

Not covered here

HUD separately identifies refinances for rehabilitation and repair and points to Section 203(k) (II.A.8.d.i(B)(3), p. 435). Fannie’s limited cash-out topic also has construction-to-permanent branches. Construction, rehab, 203(k), fix-and-flip and investment-property refinances are outside this guide.


FAQ

Is FHA no cash-out refinancing one program? No. HUD lists three types: Rate and Term (any mortgage), Simple Refinance (an existing FHA-insured mortgage), and Streamline Refinance (an existing FHA-insured mortgage, with credit qualifying and non-credit qualifying options). Each has its own occupancy, LTV/CLTV and appraisal rules.

What is the FHA Rate and Term LTV on a two-family I live in? 97.75% if the principal residence has been owner-occupied for the previous 12 months, or since acquisition if acquired within 12 months, at case-number assignment; 85% if occupied for less. The no-cash-out section does not split that figure by unit count. The maximum mortgage is also capped by the Nationwide Mortgage Limit and by existing debt plus costs.

Does an FHA Streamline need an appraisal? No. “Appraisals are not required on Streamline Refinances.” There is no maximum CLTV, and the base loan is capped by the existing loan’s balance, not an LTV.

How much cash can I get back? FHA: estimates may not produce more than $500 cash back at disbursement (escrow refunds excluded). Fannie limited cash-out: the greater of 1% of the new loan amount or $2,000. Anything more is a cash-out refinance — see /cash-out-refinance-2-4-units/.

What is Fannie’s limited cash-out maximum on a duplex or a fourplex? For a 2–4 unit principal residence the August 5, 2026 matrix lists 95% under DU, but high-balance loans are capped below 85% (2 unit) or 75% (3–4 unit), and manual underwriting lists 85% (2 units) and 75% (3–4 units). The 97% path is one-unit only.

Is Fannie’s 75% the limited cash-out ceiling for 2–4 units? Not generally. 75% is the matrix’s cash-out ceiling for a 2–4 unit principal residence. For limited cash-out, 75% is the manual figure for 3–4 units, and a high-balance 3–4 unit loan must be below 75%; the DU figure for 2–4 units is 95%. Keep loan purpose, unit count and underwriting method together when reading the number.

Does Fannie require me to have lived in the home for a set time before a limited cash-out refinance? B2-1.3-02 does not state an occupancy-duration clock. It requires at least one borrower on title at initial application (with listed exceptions), and the matrix rows quoted here are for a principal residence.

Does this page cover investment properties, 203(k) or construction? No. This site covers owner-occupied 2–4 unit homes. Rehabilitation refinances, 203(k), construction-to-permanent, fix-and-flip and investment-property rows are out of scope.

Sources

Not legal or financial advice. Figures and handbook text are dated; recheck them before you rely on them. Last reviewed 2026-11-06 by the NH Assets team.

Prepared by the NH Assets team · Not legal or financial advice · Preview build, not published

Disclosures Privacy Terms