NH Assets team · reviewed 2026-11-03
Conventional vs. FHA for a two- to four-unit home
Disclosure: duplexloan.com is published by NH Assets. We’re not a lender or mortgage broker and we don’t take applications. At launch we have no partners and receive no compensation of any kind, and all forms are off. Not legal or financial advice.
Short answer: For an owner-occupied two- to four-unit home, FHA allows a smaller minimum down payment (3.5% of adjusted value) but adds the self-sufficiency test on three and four units, a transient-use form and its own loan limits. A conventional loan sold to Fannie Mae starts at a 95% maximum LTV for a two- to four-unit principal residence under the August 5, 2026 Eligibility Matrix, so at least 5% down, with different rules everywhere else. Which one costs less depends on your numbers. Compare Loan Estimates.
General information only. Not legal or financial advice. We don’t promise rates, approvals or loan amounts. Rates are only meaningful with an APR and full terms.
Related: /fha-duplex/, /rent-from-units/, /self-sufficiency-test/, /fannie-rental-income-2-4-units/
What’s being compared
- FHA: a mortgage insured by the Federal Housing Administration under HUD Handbook 4000.1 (Update 18, last revised August 12, 2026).
- Conventional (Fannie Mae): a mortgage a lender underwrites to sell to Fannie Mae, governed by the Fannie Mae Selling Guide and its Eligibility Matrix (dated August 5, 2026).
Both assume you live in one of the units. Investor loans are a different comparison, and this page doesn’t cover them.
Side by side
| Question | FHA (HUD 4000.1) | Fannie Mae conventional (Eligibility Matrix, Aug 5, 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Least you put in | Minimum Required Investment of 3.5% of adjusted value; 96.5% maximum purchase LTV | 95% maximum LTV for a 2–4 unit principal residence purchase through Desktop Underwriter (DU). Manual underwriting is lower: 85% for 2 units, 75% for 3–4 units |
| Credit score effect | 580+: maximum financing; 500–579: maximum LTV 90% | Manual underwriting, purchase: 2 units need 680 (over 75% LTV) or 640 (75% or less) at DTI ≤ 36%, and 700 / 680 at DTI ≤ 45%; 3–4 units need 660 (DTI ≤ 36%) or 680 (DTI ≤ 45%). The matrix lists no score grid for DU |
| Loan size cap | HUD limits by county. NYC 2026: $1,599,375 (2 units), $1,933,200 (3), $2,402,625 (4) | FHFA 2026 conforming limits, NYC: $1,209,750 (1 unit), $1,548,975 (2), $1,872,225 (3), $2,326,875 (4) |
| Cash-out refinance later | Program-specific limits | 75% maximum LTV for a 2–4 unit principal residence |
| 3–4 unit rent test | Self-sufficiency: PITI ÷ net market rent ≤ 100% | The Selling Guide sections we read don’t include FHA’s self-sufficiency test. Fannie uses its own rental-income method (B3-3.8-02) |
| Other units’ rent as income | 75% of the lower of market or lease rent (no history), added to income | Monthly gross rent × 75%, minus the subject property’s PITIA. With 12+ months of property-management experience, a positive result may be used in full; with less, only to offset the PITIA (B3-3.8-02) |
| Reserves | 1 month PITI (1–2 units); 3 months (3–4 units) | 6 months’ reserves for a 2–4 unit principal residence (Selling Guide B3-4.1-01) |
| Occupancy | One borrower in within 60 days, intends to stay a year | A property the borrower occupies as their primary residence. Only one borrower must occupy and take title, except as otherwise required for mortgages with guarantors or co-signers (B2-1.1-01) |
| Family co-signer who won’t live there | Max LTV generally 75%; the 96.5% family exception doesn’t apply to 2–4 units | Manual underwriting: max LTV/CLTV/HCLTV 90% when a non-occupant’s income is used; the occupying borrower generally makes the first 5% of the down payment from their own funds unless LTV/CLTV ≤ 80%. DU assesses the risk factors for all borrowers (B2-2-04) |
| Mortgage insurance | Upfront 1.75%; annual 0.50%–0.55% up to $726,200 and 0.70%–0.75% above, by LTV (terms over 15 years) | Generally required above 80% LTV (B7-1-01), unless other charter-compliant credit enhancement is used. Cost varies by insurer; we don’t quote it |
| Extra paperwork | Form HUD-92561 (hotel and transient use) | — |
Each conventional figure above is from the dated Fannie Mae source named in that row.
Reading the down-payment row correctly
On a $1,200,000 hypothetical two-family:
- FHA: at least 3.5% of adjusted value ≈ $42,000, if adjusted value equals the price. For a purchase, adjusted value is the lesser of the price minus any inducements to purchase, or the appraised value.
- Fannie Mae: at a 95% maximum LTV, at least 5% ≈ $60,000.
That’s the minimum on each side. The matrix’s 95% and FHA’s 96.5% are both maximums. Credit score, debt-to-income, reserves and lender overlays can push either one lower. Above the conforming limit (high-balance loans), the matrix caps 2 units below 85% and 3–4 units below 75%, and those loans must be underwritten with DU.
Where FHA tends to fit
From the rules above, FHA’s structure lines up with buyers who:
- have a smaller down payment, since the minimum investment is 3.5%;
- are buying a duplex, which has no self-sufficiency test;
- want the other unit’s rent counted under a clearly defined formula.
Where conventional tends to fit
- Triplexes and fourplexes that fail FHA’s self-sufficiency test. The conventional loan doesn’t run FHA’s test, but Fannie has its own rental-income method (see the table).
- Buyers who plan a cash-out refinance later. The matrix publishes a 75% cash-out maximum for 2–4 unit principal residences.
- Buyers with a family co-signer who won’t live there. FHA’s 75% cap on 2–4 units for non-occupying borrowers is strict. On a manually underwritten Fannie Mae loan, the cap is 90% (B2-2-04).
These are patterns, not verdicts. Ask each lender to run the same property both ways.
Same property, both loans: how to compare
- Ask two or three lenders for a Loan Estimate on each loan type, using the same price and down payment.
- Compare the monthly payment (including mortgage insurance), the APR and the total closing costs on each Loan Estimate.
- On three or four units, ask the FHA lender for its self-sufficiency calculation in writing.
- Ask how the other units’ rent is counted on each loan and which figure is used.
- Ask about overlays. Lenders can be stricter than FHA or Fannie Mae.
NYC-specific checks for either loan
- Legal unit count. Both loans care how many legal units the building has. Ask your attorney to check the certificate of occupancy with NYC’s Department of Buildings.
- Mortgage recording tax. New York State and NYC tax the mortgage, and the rate depends on property type and loan size. Per NYS Form MT-15 (1/25), NYC rates per $100 of mortgage are $2.05 below $500,000; $2.175 for one- to three-family houses at $500,000 or more; and $2.80 for all other mortgages at $500,000 or more, which includes a four-family house. Ask your attorney who pays which part.
- Rent-regulated units. HCR’s Fact Sheet 1 says rent stabilization generally covers buildings built after 1947 and before 1974, and also buildings receiving J-51, 421-a or 421-g tax benefits. HCR doesn’t set a rule by unit count here. If the building may have rent-regulated units, ask your attorney to review its status before you rely on the rent.
FAQ
Is FHA always cheaper for a two-family? No. FHA’s minimum down payment is lower, but mortgage insurance and other costs differ. Compare APRs and monthly payments on Loan Estimates.
What’s Fannie Mae’s maximum LTV on a two-family I’ll live in? 95% for a purchase under the standard DU rows of the Eligibility Matrix dated August 5, 2026. That’s a maximum, and other factors can lower it.
Can I take cash out of a three-family later with a conventional loan? The matrix’s cash-out maximum for a two- to four-unit principal residence is 75% LTV.
Can I use a HELOC on a two-family? Ask lenders whether they offer one on a two- to four-unit home. HELOC rates are variable. This page doesn’t cover HELOC rules.
Sources
- HUD Handbook 4000.1, Update 18 (last revised August 12, 2026): https://www.hud.gov/sites/default/files/Housing/documents/40001-hsgh-Update-18.pdf
- HUD FHA Mortgage Limits, CY2026: https://entp.hud.gov/idapp/html/hicostlook.cfm
- Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026): https://singlefamily.fanniemae.com/media/20786/display
- FHFA 2026 conforming loan limits: https://www.fhfa.gov/news/news-release/fhfa-announces-conforming-loan-limit-values-for-2026
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-01: https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-4.1-01/minimum-reserve-requirements
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-3.8-02 (09/02/2026): https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b3-3.8-02/rental-income-subject-property
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.1-01: https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b2-1.1-01/occupancy-types
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-2-04: https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b2-2-04/guarantors-co-signers-or-non-occupant-borrowers-subject-transaction
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B7-1-01: https://selling-guide.fanniemae.com/sel/b7-1-01/provision-mortgage-insurance
- NY HCR Fact Sheet 1 (01/2024): https://hcr.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2024/01/fact-sheet-01-01-2024_0.pdf
- NYS DTF Form MT-15: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/current_forms/mortgage/mt15.pdf
Not legal or financial advice. Limits and maximums are dated; recheck before you rely on them. Last reviewed 2026-11-03 by the NH Assets team.