duplexloan

For New Yorkers buying a 2-4 family home to live in

NH Assets team · reviewed 2026-11-06

Cash-out refinance on a 2–4 unit home: FHA vs Fannie

Disclosure: duplexloan.com is published by NH Assets. We’re not a lender or mortgage broker and we don’t take applications. At launch we have no partners and receive no compensation of any kind, and all forms are off. Not legal or financial advice.

Short answer: On an owner-occupied 2–4 unit principal residence, Fannie Mae’s Eligibility Matrix caps cash-out refinance at 75% LTV/CLTV/HCLTV (DU and manual). The same matrix lists 80% for a 1-unit cash-out — keep that unit distinction. FHA allows cash-out only on an owner-occupied principal residence, with maximum LTV and CLTV of 80% of Adjusted Value. That FHA 80% figure, in the cash-out maximum section, is not split by 1-unit versus 2–4; that is a scoped observation of that section, not a claim that every other unit-specific underwriting rule disappears. Seasoning clocks differ and must not be collapsed: FHA uses 12 months of ownership and occupancy before case-number assignment, plus a separate six-payment rule when a mortgage already exists; Fannie uses a 12-month note-date-to-note-date age for an existing first mortgage and a six-month title wait before disbursement (not an occupancy clock). This page quotes the handbooks. It is not a loan decision.

General information only. Not legal or financial advice. No rate, approval, cash-out amount or loan amount is promised here. Lenders apply their own overlays in addition to FHA and Fannie rules.

Related on this site: /conventional-vs-fha/, /fha-duplex/, /nyc-2-4-unit-loan-limits/, /gift-funds-2-4-units/


The contrast in one table

Topic FHA (HUD Handbook 4000.1, Update 18) Fannie Mae (Eligibility Matrix + B2-1.3-03)
Max LTV on cash-out 80% of Adjusted Value (LTV and CLTV) 75% LTV/CLTV/HCLTV for a 2–4 unit principal residence; 80% for a 1-unit principal residence
Occupancy Owner-occupied principal residence only Principal-residence cash-out rows in the matrix; investment-property cash-out is a separate (out-of-scope) category
Ownership / occupancy clock Owned and occupied by at least one borrower as principal residence for 12 months before case-number assignment At least one borrower on title for six months before disbursement — a title rule, not an occupancy rule
Existing first mortgage age Separate rule: if there is a mortgage on the subject, at least six payments on the current loan If an existing first mortgage is paid off, it must be at least 12 months old, note date to note date (with stated exceptions)
Free and clear May be refinanced as cash-out Eligible structure includes a new mortgage on a free-and-clear property

Sources: Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026; retrieved 2026-11-06 ET); B2-1.3-03, Cash-Out Refinance Transactions (topic 12/10/2025; site footer Published November 04, 2026; retrieved 2026-11-06 ET); HUD Handbook 4000.1, Update 18 (issued 8/12/2026; refinances section labeled 11/10/2026).

The 75% Fannie cash-out maximum for a 2–4 unit principal residence is the same ceiling already noted in one sentence on /conventional-vs-fha/. This page does not rewrite that guide’s comparison tables. Published matrix ceilings are not an approval promise — other Eligibility Matrix notes and Selling Guide criteria still apply.

Do not use purchase down-payment percentages (FHA 3.5% / 96.5%, or Fannie purchase LTV maxima) as cash-out refinance ceilings. Those live on /fha-duplex/ and /conventional-vs-fha/.


Fannie Mae: 75% on a 2–4 unit principal residence

Matrix maxima (standard principal-residence cash-out)

The Eligibility Matrix dated August 5, 2026 (DU Version 12.1) lists standard principal-residence cash-out maximums for FRM/ARM:

Units DU max LTV/CLTV/HCLTV Manual max LTV/CLTV/HCLTV
1 unit 80% 80%
2–4 units 75% 75%

Source: Eligibility Matrix, printed pp. 2 and 4 (retrieved 2026-11-06 09:11:19 EST).

“Other eligibility criteria that are not covered in the Eligibility Matrix may be applicable for loans to be eligible for purchase by Fannie Mae, e.g., allowable ARM plans. See the Selling Guide for details.”

Source: same matrix, p. 1. A published ceiling is not an approval.

Out of scope: the matrix also lists Investment Property cash-out for 2–4 units at 70%. That row is not for an owner-occupied home and is not developed on this site. Do not apply it to a principal residence.

What a Fannie cash-out transaction is

Selling Guide B2-1.3-03 (topic date 12/10/2025; site footer Published November 04, 2026):

“The transaction must be used to pay off existing mortgage loans by obtaining a new first mortgage secured by the same property, or be a new mortgage on a property that does not have a mortgage lien against it (the borrower owns the property free and clear at the time of refinance).”

Acceptable uses include:

“taking equity out of the subject property that may be used for any purpose;”

Source: B2-1.3-03 (retrieved 2026-11-06 09:10:50 EST). This page does not market cash-out as a construction, rehab, or fix-and-flip product.

First-mortgage age (note date to note date)

“If an existing first mortgage is being paid off through the transaction, it must be at least 12 months old at the time of refinance, as measured by the note date of the existing loan to the note date of the new loan. This requirement does not apply […] to any existing subordinate liens being paid off through the transaction, or […] when buying out a co-owner pursuant to a legal agreement.”

Source: same B2-1.3-03 page. Keep the stated exceptions with this claim.

Six-month title wait — not an occupancy rule

“At least one borrower must have been on title to the subject property for at least six months prior to the disbursement date of the new loan, unless one of the following exceptions apply:”

Source: same page. This is a title / ownership wait before disbursement. Do not import FHA’s 12-month occupancy clock into this Fannie passage.

Documented inheritance or legally awarded property (divorce, separation, or dissolution of a domestic partnership) has no ownership waiting period under that exception, but:

“The above ownership policy applies in addition to the requirement that an existing first mortgage being paid off through the refinance is at least 12 months old.”

Source: same page. The first-mortgage-age test is not erased by the inheritance exception.

Holding time may count when the property was owned by a limited liability corporation (LLC) that is majority-owned or controlled by the borrower(s), provided ownership is transferred out of the LLC into the individual borrower(s) to close. Holding time in a qualifying inter vivos revocable trust may also count when the borrower is the primary beneficiary of the trust. Source: same page.

“Properties that were listed for sale must have been taken off the market on or before the disbursement date of the new mortgage loan.”

Source: same page.

Delayed financing — conditional exception, not a general waiver

Borrowers who purchased within the past six months (purchase date to new-loan disbursement) may be eligible for cash-out refinance only if all of the listed requirements are met, including (among others) an arms-length original purchase, a settlement statement confirming no mortgage financing was used to obtain the property, a title search confirming no existing liens, documented purchase-fund sources, and all other cash-out eligibility requirements. Cash-out pricing applies.

“Funds received as gifts and used to purchase the property may not be reimbursed with proceeds of the new mortgage loan.”

The new loan amount can be no more than the documented initial investment plus allowed financed closing costs, prepaid fees, and points, subject to the cash-out LTV/CLTV/HCLTV maxima based on current appraised value. Source: same B2-1.3-03 page.

This is a brief pointer, not the complete checklist. The full source includes additional conditions. Do not promise an exception from these excerpts alone. Gift-fund purchase rules are also covered on /gift-funds-2-4-units/.

Reserves (brief)

For DU cash-out loan casefiles, if DTI exceeds 45%, six months’ reserves are required. Source: B2-1.3-03 (also referenced from the matrix). That is not a blanket reserve statement for every DU loan.

On the manual matrix for 2–4 unit cash-out (printed p. 4; reserves in months per p. 1), example cells include: DTI ≤ 36% with score 680 → 6 months; DTI ≤ 45% with score 700 → 6 months, or score 680 → 12 months. Source: Eligibility Matrix, August 5, 2026. This page does not rewrite /fannie-rental-income-2-4-units/ or claim that Fannie has or lacks an FHA-style self-sufficiency test.


FHA: 80% of Adjusted Value, owner-occupied only

HUD Handbook 4000.1, Update 18 (issued August 12, 2026; Last Revised 8/12/2026; refinances section labeled 11/10/2026):

Definition and title before case number

“A Cash-Out Refinance is a refinance of any Mortgage or a withdrawal of equity where no Mortgage currently exists, in which the mortgage proceeds are not limited to specific purposes.”

Source: HUD 4000.1 Update 18, II.A.8.d.i(B)(1), printed p. 434.

“At least one Borrower on the refinancing Mortgage must hold title to the Property being refinanced prior to case number assignment.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.ii(B), p. 435.

Occupancy and the 12-month clock (before case number, not closing)

“Cash-out refinance transactions are only permitted on owner-occupied Principal Residences.”

“The Property securing the cash-out refinance must have been owned and occupied by at least one Borrower as their Principal Residence for the 12 months prior to the date of case number assignment.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.v(A)(1)(a), p. 437. The clock is ownership and occupancy for 12 months before case-number assignment — not closing.

Inheritance occupancy exception is conditional:

“In the case of inheritance, a Borrower is not required to occupy the Property for a minimum period of time before applying for a cash-out refinance, provided the Borrower has not treated the subject Property as an Investment Property at any point since inheritance of the Property. If the Borrower rents the Property following inheritance, the Borrower is not eligible for cash-out refinance until the Borrower has occupied the Property as a Principal Residence for at least 12 months.”

Source: same PDF, p. 437.

Occupancy documentation:

“The Mortgagee must review the Borrower’s employment documentation or obtain utility bills to evidence the Borrower has occupied the subject Property as their Principal Residence for the 12 months prior to case number assignment.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.v(A)(1)(b), p. 437.

Payment history and the separate six-payment rule

“For both Mortgages underwritten through TOTAL Scorecard and manually underwritten Mortgages, the Mortgagee must document that the Borrower has made all payments for all their Mortgages within the month due for the previous 12 months or since the Borrower obtained the Mortgages, whichever is less. […] Additionally, the payments for all Mortgages secured by the subject Property must have been paid within the month due for the month prior to mortgage Disbursement.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.v(A)(2)(a), p. 437.

If there is already a mortgage on the subject property:

“Subject Properties with Mortgages must have a minimum of six months of Mortgage Payments on the current loan. Properties owned free and clear may be refinanced as cash-out transactions.”

Source: same PDF, p. 438. The six-payment rule is separate from the 12-month ownership/occupancy seasoning. Do not substitute one for the other.

Forbearance adds a further requirement: the borrower must have completed the forbearance plan on the subject property and made at least 12 consecutive mortgage payments within the month due since completing that plan. Source: same PDF, p. 438.

Maximum LTV and CLTV

“The maximum LTV is 80 percent of the Adjusted Value. […] The maximum CLTV is 80 percent of the Adjusted Value.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.v(B)(1)(a)–(b), p. 438. This is a cash-out maximum, not a purchase-LTV rule. In that cash-out maximum section, the displayed 80% standard is not split by 1-unit versus 2–4 units — a scoped observation of that section only.

“The combined mortgage amount of the first Mortgage and any subordinate liens cannot exceed the Nationwide Mortgage Limit described in National Housing Act’s Statutory Limits.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.v(B)(1)(c), p. 438. County figures and the FHFA/FHA limit tables live on /nyc-2-4-unit-loan-limits/ — this page does not reproduce them.

Non-occupant coborrower income

“Income from a non-occupant co-Borrower may not be used to qualify for a cash-out refinance. […] Mortgagees must apply this requirement for both Mortgages underwritten through TOTAL Scorecard and manual underwriting.”

Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.v(A), p. 436. Purchase coborrower rules are not rewritten here; see /fha-duplex/ and /conventional-vs-fha/ for purchase-side contrast only.

Reserves on 3–4 units (brief)

Under TOTAL, for three- to four-unit properties the Mortgagee must verify reserves equivalent to three months’ PITI after closing. Cash taken at settlement in a cash-out transaction is excluded from reserves. Source: same PDF, II.A.4.d.i(C), p. 253. This is an underwriting reserve rule, not a second cash-out LTV tier. This page does not rewrite /self-sufficiency-test/ or /rent-from-units/.

Update 18 timing caveat

Handbook changes that are not Mortgagee-Letter changes may be implemented immediately but must be implemented no later than November 10, 2026; changes reflecting Mortgagee Letters keep their previously announced effective dates. Source: Update 18 transmittal, printed p. 7. The refinances section is labeled 11/10/2026 while footers say Last Revised 8/12/2026. This page cites the published Update 18 text; it does not claim every update was universally mandatory on November 6, 2026. No 2027 figures are invented here.

Not covered here

HUD separately identifies rehabilitation/repair refinances and points to Section 203(k). Source: same PDF, II.A.8.d.i(B)(3), p. 435. Construction, rehab, 203(k), and fix-and-flip are outside this guide.


Clocks that must stay separate

Program Clock What it measures Anchor date
FHA 12 months ownership and occupancy Principal-residence ownership + occupancy by at least one borrower Before case-number assignment
FHA Six payments on current subject loan Mortgage payments when a mortgage already exists Separate from the 12-month ownership/occupancy test; free-and-clear may still cash out
Fannie 12 months first-mortgage age Existing first mortgage being paid off Note date of old loan to note date of new loan
Fannie Six months on title At least one borrower on title Before disbursement — not an occupancy duration rule

Do not collapse these clocks into one another.


FAQ

Is Fannie’s cash-out maximum 75% or 80% on a duplex? For a 2–4 unit principal residence, the Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026) lists 75% LTV/CLTV/HCLTV for cash-out under both DU and manual underwriting. The 80% cash-out row is for a 1-unit principal residence. Keep the unit count and loan purpose explicit.

Does FHA’s 80% cash-out LTV change for 2–4 units? In the cash-out maximum section, HUD states maximum LTV and CLTV of 80% of Adjusted Value without splitting that displayed standard by 1-unit versus 2–4. That is a scoped reading of that section — not a claim that every other unit-specific underwriting rule disappears. Cash-out is still limited to owner-occupied principal residences.

When does FHA’s 12-month seasoning start and end? The property must have been owned and occupied by at least one borrower as their principal residence for the 12 months prior to case-number assignment — not closing. Occupancy is documented with employment records or utility bills. Inheritance has a conditional occupancy exception; renting after inheritance triggers the 12-month principal-residence occupancy requirement.

Is Fannie’s six-month rule about living in the house? No. B2-1.3-03 requires that at least one borrower have been on title for six months before disbursement, with stated exceptions. That is not an occupancy-duration rule. Do not treat it as FHA’s 12-month occupancy clock.

If I already have a mortgage, what else does FHA require? Separately from ownership/occupancy seasoning, subject properties with mortgages need a minimum of six months of mortgage payments on the current loan. Free-and-clear properties may still be refinanced as cash-out. Payment-history and forbearance rules in the same section also apply.

Can delayed financing waive Fannie’s six-month title wait? Delayed financing is a conditional exception for borrowers who purchased within the past six months and meet all listed requirements — not a general waiver. Gift funds used to purchase may not be reimbursed. This page is only a pointer; confirm the full B2-1.3-03 checklist with your lender.

Does this page cover investment-property cash-out or construction? No. Fannie’s investment-property 2–4 unit cash-out row (70% in the matrix) is out of scope and must not be applied to an owner-occupied home. Construction, rehab, 203(k), and fix-and-flip are excluded.

Are purchase down-payment percentages the cash-out ceilings? No. Do not use FHA’s 3.5% MRI / 96.5% purchase LTV, or Fannie purchase LTV maxima, as cash-out refinance ceilings. Cash-out maxima are the figures quoted above.

Sources

Not legal or financial advice. Figures and handbook text are dated; recheck them before you rely on them. Last reviewed 2026-11-06 by the NH Assets team.

Prepared by the NH Assets team · Not legal or financial advice · Preview build, not published

Disclosures Privacy Terms